I read an excellent article in Robin Page’s column in the Saturday Telegraph that will ring a bell with many opposing wind farms. Dr. Martina Tyrell, an anthropologist at Exeter University has addressed the issue of anecdotal evidence. We have all experienced the statements in Environmental Statements, written by academic consultants, often from a desktop survey, that we know to be palpably wrong. However all we can often offer is “anecdotal evidence”. This is seized on by the developers as having no scientific basis and therefore to be ignored. Dr. Tyrell makes the comment that conservationists and biologists often use this phrase to dismiss local knowledge as lacking in rigour and no more than the ramblings or hearsay of a farmer walking his fields. This despite their own research, at best, focusing only on specific parts of that environment. Dr. Tyrell’s studies are mostly with the Inuit and has exposed how their knowledge and expertise is routinely ignored by the conservationists and wild-life biologists in making management decisions regarding species the Inuit hunt. Dr. Tyrell further suggests that this evidence is not so different to scientific knowledge. Both are, or should be(!), founded on observation and engagement of the other senses, on experience, on experimentation and on the sharing of knowledge and expertise between and across the generations. So next time a smarmy QC tries to dismiss your evidence as ‘Anecdotal’ simply say no, it is ‘Non-Scientific Expertise’.
- Deadly Cool: Wind Turbine Throws Ice Chunks Into US College
- Do Politicians ever listen?
- Wind Industry Lies About Falling Costs Backfire: MPs Demand End to Subsidies for Wind Power
- I’ve got to take my problem to the United Nations
- I think you may enjoy this
- The Scottish Wind-Power Racket
- Cnoc an Neas
- Zero Gain
- How to really annoy your neighbours. Buy an electric car!
Wind V. Coal
Quote of the Decade
"The trouble with wind farms is that they have a very large spatial footprint for a piddling little bit of electricity. You would need 8oo turbines to produce the output of a coal-fired power station."
Sir Martin Holgate, Chief Scientist at the Department of the Environment of the British Government - October 2004
Death by a Thousand Turbines
- Energy Consents
- Kilmorack Wind Fm
- Political Comments
- The Blimp
- The Dummies Guide
Einstein on Consensus in ScienceAs Einstein once said,"It does not take a hundred scientists to prove me right ( consensus ?). It only takes one to prove me wrong"
- 134,602 views
Most recent comments
andreasmarciniak on Do Politicians ever liste… kelvinsdemon on The Scottish Wind-Power R… andreasmarciniak on I think you may enjoy thi… andreasmarciniak on The Scottish Wind-Power R… andreasmarciniak on Cnoc an Neas
Swamped by a Hundred Hydros